Posted on October 25, 2018
White poppy: How is it different from the red remembrance badge?
The 2018 poppy appeal launches on Thursday, and for two weeks many people will wear the badges to remember British soldiers who died in wartime.
But alongside the traditional red, other colours may catch your eye – white poppies, or perhaps even purple.
More people than ever before are wearing white poppies, says the group which makes them.
But they are also controversial – earlier this week, Tory MP Johnny Mercer called white poppies “attention seeking rubbish”.
But does he speak for the majority – or are white poppies a valid symbol of remembrance?
First things first…what is the difference?
Red poppies started being used as a symbol in 1921 to help us remember those who have fought in war.
The flower was chosen because it grows wild in many fields in northern France and Belgium – where some of the deadliest battles of World War One took place.
Its use was inspired by a poem, written by serving soldier John McCrae, which begins:
“In Flanders’ fields the poppies blow
“Between the crosses, row on row…”
The Royal British Legion, which sells the red poppy, is clear that the poppy is not a sign of support for war and death. Instead, they stress it is a symbol for remembrance and hope.
And the Legion is vehement the poppy should not be seen as a symbol of religion or politics.
Nonetheless, some people feel the red poppy has become political, and that politicians use it to help justify war.
Meanwhile, white poppies are distributed by the Peace Pledge Union – the UK’s oldest secular and pacifist group.
Created in 1933 – just 12 years after the red version – many people wore white poppies to stress the “never again” message, which emerged after World War One, and which pacifists feared was slipping away.
Like the red poppy, the white badge also symbolises remembrance for victims of war.
But the Peace Pledge Union says the white poppy also represents a lasting commitment to peace and the belief war that should not be celebrated or glamorised.
It also says the white poppy remembers “all those killed in war” – while the Royal British Legion says it “advocates a specific type of remembrance connected to the British Armed Forces”.
You may also see purple poppies. These are less common and created to remember the animals who die in war.
Isn’t there always a row about poppies?
Lots of people feel very strongly about wearing a red or white poppy and the issue comes up every year.
This week, Mr Mercer called on people to “ignore” those who wear white poppies.
“If you don’t want to wear a poppy don’t bother; they fought and died so you could choose,” he said. “But don’t deliberately try and hijack its symbolism for your own ends.”
Others agreed with him and directed anger at people who choose to wear a white poppy.
But some people disagree with the red poppy. Falklands veteran Simon Weston previously said he believes those who think it glorifies war are “hijacking a campaign that helps families of the injured and the dead”.
In 2014, RAF veteran and activist Harry Leslie Smith tweeted to say that he was against wearing a poppy.
And news presenter Jon Snow famously refused to wear a poppy on air, saying viewer demands for him to wear a poppy were a kind of “poppy fascism”.
He said he would wear a poppy “not on the telly… but on Remembrance Sunday in concert with others”.
So, is it ok to wear white?
The Royal British Legion says it is.
The Legion says it “defends the right to wear different poppies” – and some of its volunteers wear different colours side by side.
But it will not sell red poppies alongside other colours, because – it says – it may cause confusion.
The charity says the red poppy “is a symbol of peace inclusive of all regardless of race, belief, origin, or sexual/gender identity.
“Remembrance is neutral on both the causes and consequences of individual conflicts and is above partisan and political interpretation,” it adds.
And the Legion highlights that the red poppy raises money to support Britain’s Armed Forces, veterans and their families in their time of need.
And how popular are white poppies?
Orders have risen considerable in recent years said Symon Hill, a co-ordinator at Peace Pledge Union which makes white poppies.
“In the last four years we have sold around 100,000 each year,” he said. “The record was in 2015, when we sold 110,000. In 2017, we sold 101,000,” he said.
Sales this year – the 100th anniversary of the end of WW1 – have been “going very well” and the group has already sold more than 75,000.
“There is a realistic chance we might exceed the record,” he said.
While sales of the white version might be on the rise, they have a long way to go before they match the number of red poppies distributed every year – more than 40 million forecast in 2018, according to the Legion.
Last year, House of Lords peer Jenny Jones, from the Green Party, tweeted that she was wearing both.
And this year people have already been sharing photos of them wearing or getting ready to sell the white badges.